WC.com

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Boards, Service, and Risk

I have been privileged to serve on a few boards. Those experiences have run the gamut of stress, from stress-free to stressful. There are always issues of human dynamics and, too often, issues of money, management, oversight, and time.

The challenges have led me to resign from service only once, but I have quietly withdrawn from other boards over concerns. In still other instances, I have been scoffed at, ribbed, and even ridiculed for my conservative stance on this. More quietly still, I have chosen not to seek reelection in some instances because I thought my job there was complete. 

The two board involvements I am most proud of are the National Association of Workers' Compensation Judiciary and Kids' Chance of Florida. I'm extremely proud of both my commitment and service in bringing these two to life and the careful, thoughtful transitions they made from founders to permanency.

They are not isolated instances. I have been proud to serve on other founding boards. Those organizations have also thrived. Nonetheless, I am proudest of those two.

On the withdrawal side, I left one due to a leadership vacuum. It was one I joined well into its infancy and for which I had great hope. Following the loss of its founder, I watched its principles flounder and its leadership falter and began to doubt its spirit and commitment.

That board might have made a difference. The mission could have continued. I forewent the chance, based primarily on leadership concerns. The rest of the board followed me within a short time and the mission unfortunately ended soon after.

A second, I withdrew from over finances. The organization spent money without accountability. There were the obligatory financials displayed at board meetings. But there was no budgeting or accountability. All finances flowed through a "trusted" director who could not even explain their duties, efforts, or purpose. Almost half of annual revenue went to pay that hapless, unaccountable director.

In that instance, I strove first to explain the director's responsibilities and fiduciary roles. Those thoughts fell on deaf ears. The board had trust and faith in their director, lacked interest in examining the entity's mission, and was essentially ambivalent. The financials were never audited; questions were rarely asked and never answered.

I sensed risk there, blissful ignorance, and quietly did not run for re-election. That organization survives today, and likely still has the same deficits in mission, focus, and leadership. But regardless of its future, I am no longer tethered to its fate.

Other boards have been principled and focused. I have witnessed humanity and the potential for errors that come with it. Those are inevitabilities. Nonetheless, in those, there is also patent leadership, mission focus, and critical controls on both action and finance. I remain engaged there despite the potential for errors. 

It is an honor to serve on boards. It is also a challenge, as organizations and their leadership struggle with the day-to-day as the mission is pursued, human elements present challenges, and the world evolves around it all.

Too often, the lack of internal controls, inattentive boards, and miscreants lead to unfortunate outcomes. Those who serve on boards should take heed. Potential reading includes:
Thomas L. Hazen and Lisa Love Hazen, A Comprehensive Look at Nonprofit Directors' Fiduciary Duties, University of Pennsylvania Journal of Business Law, (2012), https://scholarship.law.unc.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1115&context=faculty_publications, last visited October 20, 2026.

Horwitz, Jill R., co-author. Letting Good Deeds Go Unpunished: Volunteer Immunity Laws and Tort Deterrence, J. Mead, co-author. J. Empirical Legal Stud. 6, no. 3 (2009): 585-635, https://repository.law.umich.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2386&context=facarticles, last visited October 20, 2026.

Hannibal B. Johnson, Legal, Ethical, and Practical Considerations for Nonprofit Board Members Getting on Board, Tulsa Law Review Volume 33 Number 2, (1997) https://digitalcommons.law.utulsa.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2132&context=tlr , last visited October 20, 2026.
Some of this reading is dated. Notably, there are important potential differences from state to state. A little specific research may be wise for anyone asked to serve. I have been amazed at board members, some lawyers, who could not comprehend or accept that they were bound by the laws of the state in which their company was incorporated. 

Board service involves important considerations. There are immense responsibilities to the organization, the community, and yourself. The potential for challenges and failures abounds. The smart volunteer will become educated on fiduciary responsibility and financial reporting and will ask the difficult questions. Competent board members will remain cautious, curious, and slightly uncomfortable.

When the uncomfortable becomes too much, when the hard questions are evaded, or the assurances are not provided, then hard choices may be necessary. 

Ask questions. Is there insurance coverage for errors and omissions? Does leadership take their role seriously? Is there some trusted employee who has unfettered control of money, information, and operations? Will insurance cover any default by such an employee or leader? Will association with the organization stain your good name?

The potential of appearing in the news may be caution enough. The potential of liability should bring caution and diligence.